Its popularity derives from the ubiquity and low cost of the main ingredients, and the fact that it is very easy to make. To get this point across, we did what we always do: organize a taste test. A Rum & Coke ratio of 1:3 might be more palatable to modern tastes. If you really want the best "Rum and Coke" make yourself a Cuba Libre using the bottled "Mexican Coke" that uses real sugar as opposed to the American corn syrup offering. Rum may not always be the most trendy option on a cocktail list, but with the third highest sales in the U.S. in 2016 behind vodka and whiskey, the spirit remains a staple of the American bar. Bartenders Share the Best Ingredients for a Top Shelf Rum and Coke. Which you can find anywhere in the world, except the U.S. And if people attending your parties were honest, they are probably tired of rum and coke's as well. Also, of course, Coke or Pepsi? Try Bacardi, Cruzan, Don Q, or Myers. What is the best rum to mix with Coke? Rum and coke is an inherently trashy drink as much I as like them, there's no real "quality" just grab whatever the liquor store has. Try a non-spiced rum. The classic recipe calls for a ratio of 1 part rum to 2 part Coca-Cola. For a simple Rum and Coke (Cuba Libre style), the building blocks are 10 oz glass, Coca-Cola, rum, ice, and lime. They're not fine rums by any means but they pair well with coke. We discovered Bones rum on our second to last trip. It features cachaça, and while it's technically not rum, it's often thought of as Brazilian rum. It’s super easy to make and an unfussy drink. Also, where to buy the rum. I always hear people order a "Captain and Coke" and, don't get me wrong, it is a delicious combination. I am "anti-Diet"....so only REAL soda for me. Pour in some rum (I like to use dark rum) and cold Coca-Cola. While rum and Coke is a near-perfect drink, these seven other mixers are just as delicious when mixed with the sugarcane spirit. Stir and you’re all set. So, you experts out there...what do you recommend for best Rum and Coke combination? Do I have to say I want a "Dark rum and coke?' Let's be honest, we're all tired of going to a gathering at our friends house and drinking the same old, cheap, low quality cocktails. Best Rum And Coke Cocktail goes together like Peanut butter and Jam. You won't find them at the trending cocktail bars in NYC or LA. You can stick to the classic and use a lime wedge, or give a cherry or orange slice a try. And don't forget to … But, enjoy a nice simple rum & coke at night. … Slice up a lime and squeeze the juice in a collins glass (about 0.75oz) then lightly muddle the spent shells in … W hat makes the rum and coke so popular is how the smooth, slightly sweet flavors come together to create a simple, refreshing cocktail you can drink all night.. As it can be made with any quantity or style of rum… No matter how you look at it, this is one of the hottest drinks in the world, and it's beyond simple: muddle lime and sugar, then add cachaça.